Milk
Milk (2008)

Milk

2/5
(16 votes)
7.5IMDb84Metascore

Details

Cast

Goofs

When marchers leave the Castro and pull the trolley pole off a PCC streetcar, the destination sign says "F Market.

" The F Market line entered service on September 1, 1995, as a tourist line between the Castro and the Embarcadero.

When Harvey Milk moves from New York City to San Francisco, a shot of Highway 280 shows modern freeway signs (bright green, with exit numbers) instead of the 1970s versions (darker green, no exit numbers).

During the Proposition 6 election, the characters mark Imperial County in red, discuss losing Imperial County, then mark it on the wall board.

Harvey quotes the inscription on the Statue of Liberty as "Your huddled masses yearning to be free.

" The actual verse is "Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.

" According to title cards at the end of the film, Dan White's lawyers argued that consumption of junk food caused a chemical imbalance in his brain.

White's lawyers actually claimed that massive consumption of junk food was a symptom of his depression, not a cause.

Psychologists employed by White's defense argued that he was clinically depressed, as evidenced by changes in behavior, including consumption of large quantities of junk food.

One psychologist claimed that junk food may have contributed to White's mood swings.

During rally scenes in the San Francisco Civic Center, the old and new San Francisco Public Library buildings are visible in the background.

The New Main Branch Library, designed by Pei Cobb Freed, was built in 1995.

Dan White shoots Moscone 3 times, and Milk 4 times.

Thought it's not shown, White reloaded between the murders.

The prosecution argued that bringing extra ammo was evidence of premeditation.

Scott swims underwater in David Goodstein's pool.

In the next shot, his head is out of the water, but his frizzy hair is dry.

When Scott leaves Harvey, Scott pets the family dog, which is sitting in an easy chair, and exits.

Harvey paces around the room immediately after, and the chair is empty.

When he sits in the chair opposite a second later, the dog is back, in the same position as before.

During Milk's speech in front of City Hall, after he reads the threatening postcard, his microphone switches between two different types.

When Milk and his allies dispose of the Coors Beer, contemporary Bud Light and Budweiser taps are visible in the bar.

Bud Light was introduced in 1982.

When Dan White is sitting shirtless looking out the window, you can clearly see a tattoo on his right shoulder blade.

Dan White's only tattoo was a shamrock on his arm.

During one of the first scenes in the camera shop, a Kodak cardboard on the shelf has a newer Kodak logo.

A scene shows Harvey Milk at the opera during the last act of 'Tosca'.

In the next scene, the next day, he says he saw Bidu Sayao, a Brazilian soprano, the night before.

Harvey was referring to his date, not anyone on stage.

Sayao never sang 'Tosca.

' At the beginning, when Scott and Harvey are lying in bed together, Scott tells Harvey he'll be "fat by 50.

" When the same scene is shown at the end of the film, Scott tells Harvey he is going to be "a fat ass.

" When Harvey Milk, Jack Lira, and a group of people stroll down Polk Street in the San Francisco Civic Center, the Civic Center Courthouse building is in the left background.

In 1978, the San Francisco Superior Court was on the fourth floor of City Hall.

The Civic Center Courthouse, designed by Hood Miller Associates and Ross Drulis Architects, was built in late 1997.

When Harvey Milk mounts a soapbox, a U.

Postal Service vehicle from the late 1980s is in the background.

When Dan White's son is baptized, two godfathers and one godmother are at the altar.

A Roman Catholic baptism includes one godfather and one godmother.

Protestant baptisms include two godparents who are the same gender as the baby, and one of the other gender.

The Chinese food containers look like old standard white containers, without the wire handles that would hold them together.

Microwavable glued containers didn't exist until fairly recently.

While the Castro Street parking meters are historically correct, modern painted T-lines (to define each parking space) are visible.

T-lines appear in the 1970s archival footage used in the 1984 documentary "The Times of Harvey Milk.

" Harvey Milk uses the term "African-American" during a speech.

While Reverend Jesse Jackson popularized the term in the early 1980s, it has existed since the 1850s.

When Milk is walking the streets gathering support to run for supervisor, one shot shows modern cars (including a black SUV) on the right side of the screen.

A red "UNITE HERE" poster is visible in the camera shop, after Harvey has given his speech on the soap box.

"UNITE HERE" formed in 2004.

When Harvey and Dan are being interviewed on TV in January 1978, Dan says he's expecting his first child.

At the baby's christening, which appears to take place a few weeks later, baby Charles can hold his head up.

Babies can usually hold their heads up at around four months old.

Also Charles White was born in mid-June 1978, after the contentious vote on the youth campus, and after Harvey's forty-eighth birthday in May.

(Dan's grudge against Harvey developed before Charles's birth, but Harvey was still invited to the christening.

) The site of the Milk/Briggs debate is incorrectly identified as the Walnut Creek Unified School District.

The debate was in the city of Walnut Creek, at Northgate High School, which was (and is) part of the Mount Diablo Unified School District.

Several times, the characters refer to The Advocate as a magazine.

In the 1970s, the Advocate was a tabloid newspaper.

It became a magazine in 1992.

In the beginning, as Harvey Milk begins to record his message, a screen card reads "1978.

" Harvey says, "Friday, November 18.

" November 18, 1978 was a Saturday.

In the camera shop during Milk's 1973 campaign for supervisor, the song "Rock the Boat" by the Hues Corporation played in the background.

But that song wasn't released until the summer of 1974, by which time Milk had already cut his hair short and was clean shaven.

In the film the clean-cut Harvey Milk didn't appear until the beginning of the 1975 campaign.

When Milk and allies dispose of Coors Beer, contemporary Bud Light and Budweiser taps are clearly seen in the bar.

When the mayor is about to sign the ordinance, the pen is in his left hand, signaling that he's left-handed.

However, the camera then cuts to a close-up to the Mayor signing the bill with his right hand.

The close-up is an insert filmed with a right-handed actor.

Awards

AARP Movies for Grownups Awards 2009


Movies for Grownups Award
Best Director

Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences of Argentina 2009


Award of the Argentinean Academy
Best Foreign Film

African-American Film Critics Association (AAFCA) 2008


AAFCA Award
Top 10 Films

Alliance of Women Film Journalists 2008


EDA Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Ensemble Cast
Best Picture

Art Directors Guild 2009


Excellence in Production Design Award
Period Film

Austin Film Critics Association 2008


AFCA Award
Best Actor
Best Film

Awards Circuit Community Awards 2008


ACCA
Best Actor in a Leading Role
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
Best Cast Ensemble
Best Director
Best Film Editing
Best Motion Picture
Best Original Screenplay

BAFTA Awards 2009


BAFTA Film Award
Best Film
Best Leading Actor
Best Make Up & Hair
Best Screenplay - Original

Berlin International Film Festival 2009


Teddy
Best Feature Film

Bodil Awards 2010


Bodil
Best American Film (Bedste amerikanske film)

Boston Society of Film Critics Awards 2008


BSFC Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Film
Best Screenplay

Broadcast Film Critics Association Awards 2009


Critics Choice Award
Best Acting Ensemble
Best Actor
Best Composer
Best Director
Best Picture
Best Supporting Actor
Best Writer

California on Location Awards 2008


COLA
Location Team of the Year - Features

Central Ohio Film Critics Association 2009


COFCA Award
Actor of the Year
Best Actor
Best Picture

Chicago Film Critics Association Awards 2008


CFCA Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Original Score
Best Picture

Chlotrudis Awards 2009


Chlotrudis Award
Best Actor

Cinema Brazil Grand Prize 2010


Cinema Brazil Grand Prize
Best Foreign-Language Film (Melhor Filme Estrangeiro)

Costume Designers Guild Awards 2009


CDG Award
Excellence in Period Film

Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards 2008


DFWFCA Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Picture
Best Screenplay
Best Supporting Actor

Danish Film Awards (Robert) 2010


Robert
Best American Film (Årets amerikanske film)

David di Donatello Awards 2009


David
Best Foreign Film (Miglior Film Straniero)

Detroit Film Critics Society Awards 2008


DFCS Award
Best Actor

Dublin Film Critics Circle Awards 2009


DFCC
Best Actor
Best Film

Film Critics Circle of Australia Awards 2010


FCCA Award
Best Foreign Film - English Language

Film Independent Spirit Awards 2009


Independent Spirit Award
Best Cinematography
Best First Screenplay
Best Male Lead
Best Supporting Male

GLAAD Media Awards 2009


GLAAD Media Award
Outstanding Film - Wide Release

Gold Derby Awards 2009


Gold Derby Award
Director
Ensemble Cast
Film Editing
Lead Actor
Lead Actor of the Decade
Motion Picture
Original Score
Original Screenplay
Supporting Actor

Golden Schmoes Awards 2008


Golden Schmoes
Best Actor of the Year

Gran Premio Internazionale del Doppiaggio 2009


Film Award
Best Leading Voice Actor
Best Picture

Hollywood Film Awards 2008


Hollywood Breakthrough Award
Screenwriter of the Year

Houston Film Critics Society Awards 2008


HFCS Award
Best Actor
Best Cinematography
Best Director
Best Performance by an Ensemble Cast
Best Picture
Best Screenplay
Best Supporting Actor

Humanitas Prize 2009


Humanitas Prize
Feature Film Category

Indiewire Critics' Poll 2008


ICP Award
Best Lead Performance
Best Supporting Performance

International Cinephile Society Awards 2009


ICS Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Editing
Best Ensemble
Best Original Score
Best Original Screenplay
Best Picture
Best Supporting Actor

International Film Music Critics Award (IFMCA) 2009


IFMCA Award
Best Original Score for a Drama Film

International Online Cinema Awards (INOCA) 2009


INOCA
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Ensemble Cast
Best Film Editing
Best Original Screenplay
Best Picture
Best Supporting Actor

International Online Film Critics' Poll 2010


IOFCP Award
Best Actor in a Leading Role
Best Ensemble Cast

Italian National Syndicate of Film Journalists 2009


Silver Ribbon
Best Non-European Director (Regista del Miglior Film Non-Europeo)

Italian Online Movie Awards (IOMA) 2009


IOMA
Best Actor (Miglior attore protagonista)
Best Cast (Miglior cast)
Best Costume Design (Migliori costumi)
Best Director (Miglior regia)
Best Editing (Miglior montaggio)
Best Original Screenplay (Miglior sceneggiatura originale)
Best Picture (Miglior film)
Best Soundtrack (Miglior colonna sonora)
Best Supporting Actor (Miglior attore non protagonista)

London Critics Circle Film Awards 2009


ALFS Award
Actor of the Year
Director of the Year
Film of the Year

Los Angeles Film Critics Association Awards 2008


LAFCA Award
Best Actor

MTV Movie + TV Awards 2009


MTV Movie Award
Best Kiss

New York Film Critics Circle Awards 2008


NYFCC Award
Best Actor
Best Film
Best Supporting Actor

Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Awards 2008


OFCC Award
Best Original Screenplay
Top Ten Films

Online Film & Television Association 2009


OFTA Film Award
Best Actor
Best Casting
Best Cinematography
Best Costume Design
Best Director
Best Ensemble
Best Film Editing
Best Picture
Best Production Design
Best Supporting Actor
Most Cinematic Moment

Online Film Critics Society Awards 2009


OFCS Award
Best Actor
Best Editing
Best Original Score
Best Original Screenplay

PEN Center USA West Literary Awards 2009


Literary Award
Screenplay

PGA Awards 2009


Stanley Kramer Award
Outstanding Producer of Theatrical Motion Pictures

Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards 2008


PFCS Award
Best Acting Ensemble
Best Performance by an Actor in a Lead Role

San Francisco Film Critics Circle 2008


SFFCC Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Original Screenplay
Best Picture

Satellite Awards 2008


Satellite Award
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
Best Director
Best Original Score

Screen Actors Guild Awards 2009


Actor
Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading Role
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role

Society of Camera Operators 2009


Camera Operator of the Year Award

Southeastern Film Critics Association Awards 2008


SEFCA Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Original Screenplay
Best Picture

Utah Film Critics Association Awards 2008


UFCA Award
Best Actor

Vancouver Film Critics Circle 2009


VFCC Award
Best Actor
Best Director
Best Film
Best Supporting Actor

Village Voice Film Poll 2008


VVFP Award
Best Actor
Best Film
Best Supporting Actor

World Soundtrack Awards 2009


World Soundtrack Award
Soundtrack Composer of the Year

Keywords

Comments